Korean Pop’s Singular Mélange

2NE1, Korean-Pop Group, at Prudential Center in Newark

NEWARK — They waited patiently, several thousand of them, outside the Prudential Center here on Friday night. They were mostly young, a combination of futuristic cool and slightly awkward. The more extravagantly attired were beyond mere extravagance: shiny clothes in bold contrasting prints, hair dyed in colors known to no rainbow.

They were K-pop fans, here for the first American performance of 2NE1, the K-pop — that’s Korean pop — stars. And they were being made to wait, unhappily, for unspecified reasons well past the time that doors were supposed to open, then also past the time that 2NE1 (pronounced “twenty-one” or “to anyone”) had been meant to take the stage. There was at least one report of fangirl tears on the street before the arena’s doors finally relented, and the crowd clogging the sidewalks was slowly herded to seats, just dodging the rain that would have compromised those outfits.

The members of 2NE1 awaited them, taking the stage in track jackets with their names — CL, Dara, Minzy, Bom — spray-painted on the back and, for some of the band, their own faces airbrushed onto the front. (The clothes for the tour were by the fantasist designer Jeremy Scott.)

“I’m going to make this show worth the wait,” CL assured the crowd, just as the group began “Clap Your Hands,”which sounded like a carbon copy of mid-2000s up-tempo R&B, and during which the group’s backup dancers were making a scene that could have been from “Breakin’ 2: Electric Boogaloo.”

K-pop moves at a speed faster than late capitalism, hybridizing styles and sounds at will and pivoting quickly. In this universe new groups are rolled out with efficiency by entertainment conglomerates; YG Entertainment is the one behind 2NE1, which in the last three years has become a huge success. (The group recently appeared in a commercial for Adidas Originals alongside Nicki Minaj.)

2NE1 is a girl group in the Destiny’s Child or Spice Girls mold, but it also incorporates plenty of rapping and some reggae for good measure, as well as production that’s indebted to arena-size dance music. Like most contemporary K-pop, the group borrows from plenty of American and European styles but manages not to carry any fingerprints — the mélange is K-pop’s signature aesthetic.

During the two-hour show this fuzzy center held up impressively, hitting a lull only late in the night during an ill-advised ballad run. When the group stuck to its exhortations to party, or boy-craziness, it was convincing.

CL is the spark plug, rapping with attitude and singing with bluster and seeking the spotlight most aggressively. During her solo turn, she mock-D.J.’ed Rihanna’s “We Found Love” on a platform high over the stage, fooling no one though enjoyable to watch all the same.

But Minzy, who had been uneven at the beginning of the night, ended up being the group’s anchor, singing with confidence and a rich tone, and even dancing in a way that kept up with the hyperactive backing troupe. During her solo turn she break-danced to Missy Elliott’s “I’m Really Hot.”

Dara, with half her head shaved, was the most coy of the group. She sings in a thin, velvety tone that’s best as an accent. Bom, for her part, aimed higher, with ambitious vocals that didn’t always hit their marks. She appeared less and less steady as the night progressed. Each time the group left the stage she was the one trailing behind, either legitimately confused or playing the part well.

2NE1 was backed by a mostly female band, which injected flourishes of real skill amid the music’s more direct demands. It shined on the restrained pop-house of “In the Club,” and also the Kylie Minogue-esque disco of “Stay Together” and the winning “I Love You.”

Even smaller songs were presented in huge fashion, thanks to the dozen or more backup dancers and elaborate video-screen projections. During “Pretty Boy,” the male dancers removed their shirts, one after the other, and one of them walked the length of the U-shaped stage in a Flaming Lips-style inflatable ball.

Despite all the pageantry there was still something slightly unfinished about this performance, with its emphasis on scale and spectacle, not on polish and finesse. There were dance moves not quite executed to their finish, sporadic lip-syncing and some vocal parts rendered shakily.

At the encore 2NE1 delivered a second rendition of “I Don’t Care” — this one reggae-less — and closed with its hit single “I Am The Best,” one of its most dynamic songs, all squelchy synths and abusive drums and slithery vocals. At this point they were dressed casually; following a night of glittery basketball jerseys and psychedelic leggings, it was the equivalent of seeing them in their pajamas. After all, it was late.

Source: The New York Times

Comments on: "Article: New York Times – Korean Pop’s Singular Mélange" (28)

  1. aix009's avatar

    i would have to agree on the comment regarding bom… i sometimes have that comment…

    i have nothing against this but i guess that is why it was difficult for fans to accept/ read this is because it is quite obvious that the writer is not a kpop fan and is not fond of the style/ hype whatever….. the writer made a story out of something he really does not want/ care to learn and appreciate. The writer before the show has an established view already, the problem is…. he did not open his mind for appreciation during the show that is why his article is like a bitter pill.

    this article shows the kind of writer he is. …not good

    *i’m speaking as judge of his article as a whole *

    • ckjack_bla's avatar
      ckjack_bla said:

      Agree. Although the article speaks of the truth, I think it’s not really impartial. He sounded like he wouldn’t consider 2NE1/KPop music… ever.

  2. shari's avatar

    Everybody makes a mistake :)) and I know they will learn from aside from technical errors.. the GIRLS made the night unforgettable for the fans.. the most important thing is the FANS love it.. beside they are the one 2ne1 needs to please not this critics, lol! :)))

  3. inky's avatar

    This review i kinda agree. I think yg debut them in
    united states so fast the preparation is not enough us is not easy country to please!i hope the girls stay strong.

    • QW's avatar

      yeah…..US debut= its really really really HARD (for asian)!!!!He should be totally focused on 2ne1!!!ugh…..the theme song for kpop idol’s US debut, is “The Hardest Ever” by Will i am ft JLo.

  4. b3bz21's avatar

    these comments were quite insulting… but we all that truth hurts…

  5. vainkill's avatar

    Don’t take critics too seriously in their words. Especially with this non kpop fan. You are just making them smarter than the rest of us. The writer has a big say because he/she is a pundit. But so what? Just take his word with a grain of salt. Without a privilage his piece will not carry weight at all.

  6. ckjack_bla's avatar
    ckjack_bla said:

    Writers/Music critics – One of the many obstacles that 2NE1 will encounter in the US music industry. I hope 2NE1 and YGE will read this article so that they will be more prepared for their debut. Stay strong 2NE1!!! F-I-G-H-T-I-N-G!!!

    • ckjack_bla's avatar
      ckjack_bla said:

      SHOUTOUT TO PAPA YG:

      Focus your attention to 2NE1!!! Their US debut is nearing!!! It’s make it or break to the US!!! :-/

  7. Maria's avatar

    Just because he is from the NYT doesn’t necessarily mean I should agree with him totally nor do I believe this is the review of others who were previously not into KPop and caught the show. The Ballad portion for instance was warmly received and definitely no lull there. I think the critic was just sulking because he was put off by the delay in the show which was not YG’s fault but the venues’. The concert was amazing and if the audience felt they got their money’s worth (which was not cheap) then that’s SUCCESS!!

  8. ethel's avatar

    this..review..is..a..critiques..perspective..As..a..fan,..the..girls..should..take..this..positively….to..their..advantage..as..to..improve..their..craft..to..take..on..the..world..as..to..break..barriers..in..the..universal..music..industry!!!

  9. joy (@akikisetsu)'s avatar

    The review does not come across as offensive. It seems fair enough and you can just take it as constructive criticism. But, I think it didn’t help that they started an hour or so late. I know this is not related, but sometimes I just wish that YGe would stop using 2ne1’s activities as “dry runs”. It seems that way,sometimes. I know he cares about them, but a little planning/promo on 2ne1’s activities goes a long way.peace out!^^

  10. tangerine_24's avatar
    tangerine_24 said:

    ok now I’m confused…so CL wasn’t really DJ-ing??? I think comments about Minzy and Dara were good. ..I just feel a little bad about Bom’s..but overall I think it’s an honest review. I hope all the girls get to read this so they could improve their performance 🙂

  11. peebee's avatar

    AGREEE, yeah all caps ^^ this review is fair, honest and spot on! i super luv dara and i am not offended AT ALL by what was written about her. “coy” could mean yes, shy and or nervous which she most probably is considering this their 1st major show in the US, or it could also mean somebody that stays in the background…that she’s not the “frontman” of the group,oh well woman in this case, which she never pretended or intended to be. the word “accent” means someone whose there to add and or enhance whatever is needed or make it even better in looks, sound or performance. and for reason, the fact that her good looks was never even mentioned makes me feel good. ‘coz her haters always use that against her, as if its a sin to be beautiful.

    • bratty21's avatar

      wow… i love your POV…. good point there…

    • Darlene Kylie Miza (@darkymiza88)'s avatar

      i agree that he did gave his review fairly and i agree, too, that Dara-eonnie’s beauty not being mentioned is a great thing…even eonnie admits that it hurts her when people only see her as being beautiful…although this review hurts, it’s acceptable…^^hwaiting, 2ne1!!!

    • QW's avatar

      100%Agree!!!!!!”its a sin to be beautiful”…..Dee haters= they’re ugly inside out!!!!
      the theme song for Dee haters is “Pretty girl rock” by Keri Hilson

  12. Boopie's avatar

    some review. makes a kpop fan feel anything but happy. Well its ok. at least the person knows how to write words and paragraphs

  13. Johnson Sarin (@JohnsonSarin)'s avatar
  14. Missy musni's avatar
    Missy musni said:

    What is a coy ?? Can someone tell me I don’t understand Dara’s part .. “was the most coy of the group “

    • BJ's avatar

      I had no idea what coy meant so I googled it and found that coy can mean “modest”, “shy” and “timid”. So I guess Dara comes across as being shy? That kinda fit with Dara’s personality!

    • ethel's avatar

      coy..means..shy…

  15. meg (@typecastheroine)'s avatar

    This wasn’t exactly a flattering review, but honest and fair – or at least gives a perspective of a non-Kpop fan’s intro to the genre (which I assume the author is). Or maybe the author was just in a bad mood for having to wait before the concert started. I hope that the fans keep cool, and for YG to take notes about what to the be improved for the LA leg of the concert.

    • nana:)'s avatar

      Agree:)

    • oh dara!'s avatar

      I actually like this review. It lays it down as it is. Its a refreshing take on 2NE1, their concert and their music. Its not exactly flattering but its honest and fair. It is what it is. As a fan, I am not offended by how this review was written. Its actually nice to hear the view of a non-Kpop fan. It puts things in perspective once in a while. ^^

    • BJ's avatar

      Agree too. I find the review quite honest and hope 2NE1 will continue to improve as this was their first world tour concert! There is definitely room for improvement!

Leave a reply to shari Cancel reply