2NE1’s “Collection” was reviewed by The Japan Times Online. I love how they described Dara as “sassy with a touch of ironic self-awareness.” True, our Goddess is very sassy.

Unfortunately, I also agree that their closing cover of Madonna’s “Like A Virgin” was a “pointless, deflating end to the album”. Other than the CM, I honestly found no use for their cover. And dare I say it, I actually found it *gasp* bad! T_T

What do you guys think of their review of 2NE1’s “Collection”?

LISTENING POST: 2NE1’S “COLLECTION”

With Korean idol groups now saturating the Japanese pop market to the extent that the initial breath of fresh air and rush of slick, electropop energy is passing, it takes a more seasoned kind of fan to differentiate between the legions of immaculately rehearsed Girls’ Generation clones. But with Japan slow to respond with forward-thinking pop of its own, the task falls to another Korean group to blow K-pop apart.

2NE1 have a habit of reminding the listener of the group’s name every three or four seconds during the first half of this first Japanese-language album, and like a Korean TLC composed of four Lisa “Left Eye” Lopezes, every moment buzzes with that most misused word in pop music — attitude. Main rapper CL’s spoken word intros are full of swagger, Park Bom is as fine a singer as they come, Dara is sassy with a touch of ironic self-awareness, and Minzy … well, she’s a good dancer.

In a way, 2NE1’s closest Japanese equivalent is probably idol group Momoiro Clover Z. While they come from radically different musical backgrounds, they share a seamless integration of personality, image and music, with each element mutually complementary. They also share a completely batty, everything-and-the-kitchen-sink approach to songwriting. “I Am the Best,” already familiar from last year on the “Nolza” mini-album, is a particularly striking example with its collision of manic house music bleeps, crunching electro synths, tribal drumming and Indian/Middle Eastern melodies sounding like absolutely nothing else on earth. What do you even call that music? Dutch electro-Bollyhouse? Who even cares?

The inclusion of “I Am the Best” alone would have marked “Collection” out as a contender for album of the year, but it practically machine-guns you with similar moments. Even where they get all serious and emotional, glorious moments shine through the schmalz — CL comparing the end of a relationship with Beyoncé leaving Destiny’s Child in “Go Away” can’t help but raise a smile.

Unfortunately, the closing cover of Madonna’s “Like a Virgin” is a pointless, deflating end to the album. However, recent single “Scream” shows off the talents of the group’s production team, who are keeping 2NE1 one step ahead of the electropop crowd. Reworked versions of older songs such as “Fire,” “Follow Me” and “Clap Your Hands” retain the scattershot arrangements and chimp-going-crazy-with-the-autotune-knob-style madness that made them so gloriously silly and downright fun in the first place.

K-pop is dead: Long live K-pop.

Source: The Japan Times Online

Comments on: "Article: The Japan Times Online: LISTENING POST – 2NE1 “Collection”" (16)

  1. edherei's avatar

    Reblogged this on edherei.

  2. tigerlily25's avatar
    tigerlily25 said:

    I actually agree with the article. I for one have long gone followed their Japanese album, and I know for a fact that Japanese have a different taste when it comes to music and 2NE1’s brand…suffice to say is that they are slow when appreciating this type of music. I think for once they gave Dara the right words and must agree with it whole heartedly coz she can really make it to their market. 🙂 As for Like a Virgin cover…enough said! Wrong song at all.

  3. jangy's avatar

    good article overall, positives mostly. i cant disagree on Like A Virgin. It’s a great classic pop song by an iconic artist such as Madonna. but bad cover. some fans were like the song is too soft for 2NE1 or something. well, they shouldve let Dara sing more coz her voice is perfect for pop. and if u listen to 2NE1’s first mini, the songs there have this pop feel that 2NE1 pulled off very well, so they couldve pulled it off. idk. i just wasnt feeling it as much as i’d want to, but definitely loved Dara’s parts in that song.

    • QW's avatar

      100%AGREE!!!This style of music suit her voice the best. Her voice is so sweet and girly. I would luv to hear her singing Kylie minogue’s songs.

  4. skye05's avatar

    can somebody pls enlighten me what does “sassy with a touch of ironic self-awareness” mean? and minzy is definitely a lot more than just a good dancer…our maknae is amazingly talented!

    sadly, i have to agree though with regard to their “like a virgin” cover…i don’t get why it had to be that song…

    and oh, the last line in the article seems to be contradicting… >__<

    • jangy's avatar

      im not sure either… perhaps the fact that she can be confident on stage yet be really shy in person?

      and agree with Minzy… she’s not just a good dancer, she’s a great dancer and great singer too, and a lot lot lot more, and she’s slowly but surely priming herself to shine individually just like her unnies.

  5. QW's avatar

    japan always tries to find fault with 2ne1(song/mv)…ugh!!and why YG gave 2ne1 a wrong song choice/ many recycling songs?….ugh!!

  6. cheneechee's avatar
    cheneechee said:

    I like their comment about dara ❤
    and kinda agree about Like A Virgin comment too LOL
    It's a commercial song anyway hahaha

  7. peebee's avatar

    i can mlive with that review BUTwhat i dont like about it is the comparison with momoiro clover z… have any of you seen that group? go watch them on YT and tell me if i’m wrong in thinking… its an ABSOLUTELY STUPID comparison.

  8. εїзOMG♥DARAling★☜♤☞ (@SHABAM_2ne1Bang)'s avatar

    I do agree with the critic of Like A Virgin..i like it but not so much like their original songs…but about my baby Minggki 😦 she’s not just a dancer…she’s a full package of talent..she’s the second voice i love about 2ne1 :(…Its ok baby Minggki prove them wrong next time.. ❤

  9. egliukas's avatar
    egliukas said:

    i don’t agree about Minzy ! maknae is full of talents and she has a great voice >,<

  10. ilovessantokki's avatar
    ilovessantokki said:

    Fair review and love what they said about Dara, but I wish they’d said better things about Minzy. The girl is oozing with talent. They shouldn’t just put her off as “just a good dancer.”

    -.-

  11. Dara4ever's avatar
    Dara4ever said:

    Yeah,..0n their like a virgin c0ver,.,i can 0nly rec0gnize Dara’s v0ice..but 0verall its go0d..

  12. JJ's avatar

    Yeah have to agree with the “like a virgin” comment. When I first heard the song I could not differentiate between the three girls, lucky for me that Dara’s voice stands out but I didn’t like that I could hear her drawing breaths a tad too loud. Other than that it was alright. Not really a fan of remaking old songs into Japanese as I have gotten so used to their Korean songs it just sounds too different for me to like. Scream was great but collection was okay.

  13. Miho's avatar

    and Minzy … well, she’s a good dancer.—–ehhhhhhhhhhhhh! she’s more than that, you know

  14. knownlurker's avatar
    knownlurker said:

    Kinda agree with Like A Virgin comment. It did nothing to the album. I can’t barely recognized who’s singing other than Dara.

Leave a reply to cheneechee Cancel reply